Discovering a Secret Nazi
Discovering
a Secret Nazi
Bob Sredersas and the Gift
Interviewer: Let’s see if we can get this working…
Bob Sredersas: Don’t trust no-one, even don’t trust me.
Interview
with Bob Sredersas by student journalist Karen Lateo
29 May 1981
The
Story
On 27 July 1976, the people of
Wollongong awoke to some wonderful news. A retired steelworker, Bronius ‘Bob’
Sredersas, had gifted his collection of artworks, which the Illawarra Mercury reported was worth
“millions”, to the Wollongong City Council. He told the city’s aldermen that his
bequest was “not for Peter or John, but for Wollongong, especially the young
people.”[1]
It was a generous gift, which
Sredersas, a 65-year-old retired migrant steelworker, added to in subsequent
years. By the time of his death on 26 May 1982[2], the gift totalled 87
artworks (paintings, drawings, woodcuts and etchings), 11 objects from Papua
New Guinea, 31 pieces of china and five miniatures. Artistic highlights
included works by Nicholas Chevalier, Will Ashton, Sydney Long, Grace
Cossington Smith, Hans Heysen, Rupert Bunny, Arthur Streeton and Margaret
Preston.[3]
For Wollongong, as it was in
the 1970s, the gift was startling. The city was a centre for heavy industry and
did not even have an art gallery. The gift acted as a catalyst for the
establishment, by the Wollongong City Council and New South Wales (NSW)
Government, of the Wollongong City Gallery. Looking back, an alderman, Harold
Hanson AM, explained the critical role Sredersas’ gift had played:
Bob wanted to show his gratitude to Wollongong for
giving him a home, by donating his collection to the City to be available to be
seen by the children. He knew that he was getting older and he wanted to make
sure that the gift was in the care of the City before he died. He also wanted to be sure that they, or at least a
rotating selection of them, would be put on permanent display so that the
children of his adopted City would be able to see them whenever the Gallery was
open.
His collection and magnificent donation – worth a
very substantial amount of money indeed – was the catalyst on which the Art
Gallery and its collection were built.
With his consent the fund-raising Committee was able to publicise the donation and use it as a platform to launch a much larger fund-raising project. The Mercury gave Bob Sredersas and the collection a tremendous amount of publicity in support of the Gallery project.[4]
In line with this strategy, Sredersas’
benefaction was widely celebrated in the following years, and in the decades
after his death. The Illawarra Mercury
advised readers in an editorial that “there should be more men like him.”[5]
The aspiring artists of the region honoured him with portraits and Sredersas
estimated that he had sat for 30 of them. The inaugural Gallery
Director, Tony Bond, selected one for the Gallery’s collection, which he said was
“a gesture of appreciation to Mr Sredersas’ generosity.”[6]
Official recognition followed with the Wollongong City Council naming an
exhibition space within the new gallery in his honour[7]
and he was photographed being introduced to the NSW Premier, the Hon Neville
Wran QC MP, at the gallery’s official opening.[8]
Eminent persons of the calibre of Donald Horne, Barry Jones, and Imants Tillers
gave lectures in his honour.[9]
The gallery mounted exhibitions and erected a plaque, while the Wollongong Art
Gallery Friends Committee hosted the Sredersas Dinner as a fundraising social event.[10]
"New Wollongong City Gallery" - a 1991 screenprint by Gregor Cullen celebrating the contribution of Bob Sredersas on the occasion of the Wollongong City Gallery's move into new premises
Wollongong is a mystery thrown up from the puzzles of
industrial change. Building and rebuilding are conducted with twentieth century
technique but in a goldrush muddle. People from 40 or 50 nations make up
Wollongong – in the steel works migrant labour runs as high as 50 per cent. It
is by far the most frontier-like of Australia’s bigger cities, spreading and
sprawling to God knows where.”[13]
As this industrial economy and culture were peaking, Wollongong began to change. In 1975, the University of Wollongong was established as an autonomous higher education institution.[15] In the same year, the F6 toll road between Waterfall and Bulli opened, enabling much improved road access to the cultural and economic opportunities available in Sydney. At the opening of the Wollongong Art Gallery in 1978, the Lord Mayor Frank Arkell summed up the mood:
For too many years we have suffered from the problems of rapid growth and too much emphasis on heavy industry. Now there was (sic) a breathing space and time to change the emphasis to the environment and the enjoyment of the arts.[16]
Sredersas’ gift arrived at just the right
time to realise these changing aspirations.
Port Kembla steelworks
Sredersas
himself had arrived in Wollongong in 1950 as one of the 170,700 displaced
persons who, in the years 1947 to 1953, left post-war Europe to make new lives
for themselves in Australia. At the war’s end there were hundreds of thousands
of people in Germany, originating from across Europe, who could not or would
not return home, usually because of a well-founded fear of persecution from
Stalin in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR)[17] or his proxies across
Eastern Europe.[18]
Migrants in employment in Australia - Port Kembla steelworks, 1955
In 1949 Sredersas received a Good Conduct Statement[20] from officials at his camp and, having been selected as suitable to make a new life in Australia, arrived in Melbourne on 23 May 1950 as one of 1,877 displaced persons aboard the Fairsea, which had left Bremerhaven, Germany, on 18 April 1950.[21] The passengers disembarked and boarded a special train which took them to the Department of Immigration’s Reception and Training Centre at Bonegilla, Victoria. Soon after, Sredersas arrived in Wollongong and commenced his employment at the Port Kembla steelworks, where he was to work without incident for the next 25 years.
In 1979, looking back on his arrival in Wollongong after a journey that had taken him across the world and a long way from both the war years and his Lithuanian homeland, Sredersas told the Illawarra Mercury:
“It was night and cold and I saw these big fires and lights
from the ovens and I said, ‘This is the work for me.’”[22]
For a reader in 1979, this would seem a nostalgic statement about the Port Kembla coke ovens that lit up Wollongong’s night sky.
For a reader in 2022, it reads as an attempt to be surreptitiously sardonic.
The
Backstory
Bronius Sredersas was born on 4 December 1910, in Simferopol, a Crimean city within the Russian Empire of Tsar Nicholas II. His birth was recorded in the register of the Simferopol Roman Catholic Parish Church, with his full name Bronislav Kuratol Franzel Scherger Schreders. His parents, recorded as being lawfully married, were Maximillian Gustav Theophil Heinrich Leon Schreders and Anna-Maria (nee Schneider). His parents were “noble-persons” of the Kovno region in the district of Ponieviz.[23] Kovno was then a city within the Russian Empire but today, more than 100 turbulent years later, is known as Kaunas and is one of the largest cities in the Republic of Lithuania.[24]
In 1982, Sredersas told the Illawarra Mercury that after the First World War, with Russia enduring revolution and civil war, his family fled the Crimea, travelled through Romania and Poland, and returned to Lithuania. On 16 February 1918, amidst the chaos of war and the Russian revolution, Lithuania declared its independence, which it successfully defended during the course of several wars in the next three years. Despite this political turmoil and military conflict, Sredersas remembered Lithuania as a peaceful place in which to grow up.[25]
The
family’s move across Europe involved the assumption of a new name reflecting
the change from Russian to Lithuanian in language, alphabet and cultural
traditions. Lithuanian surnames appear in three forms, one masculine and two
feminine, and the suffix “-as” is an accepted male formulation. [26] The surname ‘Schreders’ thus
became ‘Sreders-as’, expressed as ‘Sredersas’.
Along
with a steady set of promotions, Sredersas also undertook several training
courses, including one on chemical defence, and was transferred to the city of Vilnius
in late 1939. This transfer would have been part of the larger movement of government
officials (and ethnic Lithuanians) from Kovno to Vilnius, following the city’s return
to Lithuanian control. The return of Vilnius, known as the Lithuanian Jerusalem
because of its large Jewish population,[33] was a gift from the
Soviet Union and took place after Hitler and Stalin had dismembered Poland
subsequent to the Nazi-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact. Initially welcomed by
Lithuanians, it soon became clear that this gift came with many strings
attached. Bases for the Red Army were established, a puppet government was
installed and by mid-1940 Lithuania was formally incorporated into the USSR.
Inspired by the Nazi’s identification of the Jews with Bolshevism, the killings of Jews began immediately. At Kovno, even before the German Army arrived on 23 June, a Lithuanian mob murdered hundreds of Jews who had been accused of collaborating with the Russians.[40] More ghastly killings took place on 27 June when a large crowd of Lithuanians, including women and children, gathered at the Lietukis garage to watch dozens of Jews beaten, hosed with water and clubbed to death by Lithuanian activists. The crowd urged the killers on with shouts and applause.[41]
Massacre at the Kovno Garage – June 1941
Reports prepared by Karl Jaeger, the commanding officer of the SD Einsatzkommando 3, documented the scale of the killings. By 1 December 1941, 137,346 people had been murdered. While the vast majority were Jews, the Jaeger Report’s lists of victims also included several hundred communists, a handful of Russian prisoners of war, criminals, and 544 people described as ‘lunatics’. Jaeger reported to his superiors in Germany:
“I can state today that the goal of solving the Jewish
problem in Lithuania has been reached by EK 3. There are no Jews in Lithuania
anymore except the work-Jews and their families, which total
in
Siauliai some 4,500
in
Kovno some 15,000
in
Vilna some 15,000”[43]
Einsatzgruppen or their auxiliaries – Kovno 1942
By the time the Germans were driven out of Lithuania, around 95 per cent of the country’s Jews were dead, the highest proportion in the whole of Nazi-occupied Europe.[47] The Lithuanian historian Arunas Bubnys has calculated that the number of Lithuanian Jews murdered totalled 195,000, plus several thousand more who had been transported from across Europe to be executed in Lithuania.[48]
The successful implementation of Nazi policy to destroy Lithuania’s Jews was accomplished with the active participation of non-Jewish Lithuanians. The murder of such vast numbers proceeded shot by shot, not by the deployment of mass killing instruments like gas chambers, and the Germans relied on local collaborators simply because they did not have enough men for the job.[49] Jaeger, in his report, noted how his success had been due in part to the “co-operation of the Lithuanian partisans” and to the availability of “a sufficient number of trained partisans.”[50]
When applying to the IRO for assistance, Sredersas said he was unemployed from August 1940 to December 1943, when he became a seaman. He said he held this position to June 1944 when he took flight ahead of the Russians due to “political reasons.” By September 1944 he was in Germany, working as a cook in Heilsberg, before being evacuated in January 1945.[51] After the war, he spent time in various displaced persons camps, including Flensburg (also known as the Antwerp-Westerallee Camp) and Meierwik in Germany, and in 1947 attended the IRO Navigation and Sea - Engineering School at Flensburg,[52] before arriving in Australia in 1950.
Post-war
Australia had only a rudimentary understanding of what would come to be known
as the Holocaust. The long boom of the post-war years was underway, as was the
baby boom, and the prevailing national mood was optimistic about the future
rather than being pre-occupied with the past. Australia was about to enter a
period of economic expansion and prosperity greater than it had ever
experienced. The 1950s was a time of unprecedented consumerism, with suburban
families acquiring cars, televisions, vacuum cleaners, washing machines and
lawn mowers. Melbourne hosted the 1956 Olympic Games, and in 1957 Sydney, not
to be outdone, decided on the design for its opera house.[53] Australia was also an active participant in
the Cold War, with the Korean War, the Petrov Affair, a referendum on banning
the Communist Party of Australia, and a major split in the Australian Labor Party,
all reminding Australians there were current political events to be concerned
about.
Sredersas seems to have recognised this lack of awareness and knowledge. In 1981, invited by a student journalist to reflect on what life was like in Lithuania, he said:
“You don’t even know after the second war how it was because here in Australia you don’t know nothing.”[58]
Several questions later he broke down in tears, professing his love for Australian art.
Sredersas
made no effort to explain in detail “how it was” in the war, preferring to maintain
a silence about his life and activities before his arrival in Australia. The
executor of his will, Father Michael Bach of the Catholic Diocese of Wollongong,
said his movements during the war were “pretty cloudy”,[59] while then Alderman
Harold Hanson said of Sredersas:
“He told us that he had arrived in
Australia from Northern Europe. He was very reticent about his upbringing but
Lithuania did get a mention.”[60]
Picking up this cue, a week later, on 22 March 1961, the Attorney-General, the Honourable Sir Garfield Barwick QC, announced that the Menzies Government had refused the extradition, sought by the USSR, of Ervin Viks for alleged war crimes committed in Estonia during the war. Viks had also arrived in Australia in 1950 as a displaced person and was alleged to have personally participated in mass shootings, but Barwick declared “the time has come to close the chapter. It is, truly, the year 1961,” and explained Australia’s position:
“…there is the right of this nation, by receiving people
into this country, to enable men to turn their backs on past bitternesses and
to make a new life for themselves and for their families in a happier
community.
“In default of a binding obligation requiring Australia at
this point of time to do otherwise, these, who have been allowed to make homes
here, must be able to live, in security, new lives under the rule of law.”[65]
A Different Story
In
1954 my father, a Greek farm labourer, arrived in Australia not as a displaced
person but under the auspices of the Intergovernmental Committee for European
Migrants, which provided assisted passage for Europeans who wished to migrate
to Australia. Soon after his arrival he, like Sredersas and thousands of other
migrants, commenced work in the steelworks. The steelworks were, for most of
the next 40 years, the mainstay of my father’s working life and my childhood was
replete with discussions about his work at the sinter plant, slab caster, oxygen
plant and coke ovens.
“An immersive, interactive installation project that celebrates the significant and generous gift by Bronius (Bob) Sredersas, a Lithuanian migrant and steel worker whose personal art collection became the impetus for the establishment of Wollongong Art Gallery.”[68]
The comprehensive nature of the exhibition signalled that it was a major cultural event. There was an installation recreating Sredersas’ Cringila home furnished with his paintings; a video depicted him walking around the steelworks with a painting under his arm; displays of Lithuanian dancing; and talks with people who knew him and that instructed the audience about “Bob and other organic intellectuals of the working class who helped make Cringila the birthplace of high art in the Illawarra.”[69] A fundraising event, the Sredersas Dinner and Lecture, was organised by the Wollongong Art Gallery Friends Committee.
Promotional flyer for the fundraising Sredersas Dinner & Lecture, 2018Media coverage of the exhibition highlighted that Sredersas had been a “secret service officer” or “policeman” in Lithuania before migrating to Australia.[70] The articles referred to his past being “shrouded in mystery” and the curator of the exhibition, Anne-Louise Rentell, was said to be “keen to continue uncovering information about Sredersas’ past.”[71] All of this intrigued me because, while I knew of Sredersas’ years spent working in the steelworks, until then I was unaware of his career in the Lithuanian secret service. I knew though, that the Nazis relied on local collaborators to carry out the Holocaust and that Auxiliary Police Battalions were central to the killing of Jews and others in Lithuania. I was appalled at the possibility that Wollongong, my home town, could have been unknowingly honouring a Holocaust perpetrator for decades, and decided to find out if Sredersas had been involved in wartime atrocities.
In
the IRO papers Sredersas had provided a record of his employment for the
previous 12 years, and declared he was unemployed from August 1940 to December
1943. This was peculiar as it was not clear how anyone could survive being
unemployed in wartime Lithuania, as the Nazis did not invade a country to
provide social security payments to the local population. There was supporting
testimony provided by another displaced person, Juozas Krucas, to the effect
that during the war, Sredersas was a farmer and “was neither a soldier nor
police.” This was interesting as just two pages earlier, Sredersas had said he
was unemployed, now a referee was stating he was a farmer. Krucas’ contention
that he hadn’t been a soldier or a policeman seemed to come from nowhere. What
was the purpose of such an unsolicited and pre-emptive denial?
“The public disclosure of this information and other relevant details could be used by organisations or individuals of national security interest to take counter measures against security operations.” [75]
To evaluate this I contacted the author and researcher Mark Aarons, the leading expert on the way Holocaust perpetrators found refuge in Australia. I had previously read his books on the subject, and felt he could give me a sense of how to interpret the information I had.[76] His response was clear and direct:
“In light of Sredersas’ position in the secret police in Kovno, which was the site of major war crimes, I think he was likely involved in the mass killings of Jews and others. It would have been highly improbable that someone who held a position in the Lithuanian police would not have participated in such mass killings, especially as the Nazis formed special units of “auxiliary police”, the job of which was to slaughter.”[77]
He
also pointed out that a decision to withhold sections of a naturalisation file
was unusual and would likely have been taken on the advice of the Australian
Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO), which recruited former Nazis as
informers during the Cold War. I therefore applied to see if there was an ASIO
file on Sredersas, but was advised:
No records relating to SREDERSAS, Bronius in the open period as defined by the Archives Act 1983 (the Act), currently records created up to and including 1996 and 1997, can be found.[78]
With
no ASIO files in existence, I then appealed the decision of the National
Archives of Australia to withhold sections of Sredersas’ naturalisation papers.
This process established what was being withheld was only the name of the ASIO
officer who had provided a routine naturalisation clearance.[79] If Sredersas was a Nazi
collaborator, he had kept this hidden from ASIO along with everyone else.
The document confirming Sredersas' place in the Tsar's aristocracy
In general, it should be stressed that the role played in the Holocaust by Lithuanian police battalions was particularly significant. Although almost every type of Lithuanian police force (public police, security police, auxiliary police, partisan (white armband) took part in the persecution and murder of Jews, their role in the Holocaust was not so important as that of the police battalions (or ‘self-defence’ units).[89]
I had learnt a lot about Bob Sredersas and the Holocaust in Lithuania, and was increasingly sure he had been involved. But while all the circumstances suggested this, there was still nothing definitive. Even so, I was determined to learn more and the pandemic lockdowns of 2020 and 2021 provided me with ample time to think about fugitive war criminals. I read Gitta Sereny’s Into That Darkness: From Mercy Killing to Mass Murder[90], which recounts her time with Fran Stangl, the former Kommandant of the Treblinka extermination camp, and Gerald Steinacher’s more recent Nazis on the Run: How Hitler’s Henchmen Fled Justice[91]. I read fictional works including Martin Amis’ Time’s Arrow and Bernhard Schlink’s The Reader, watched films like The Boys from Brazil and Marathon Man, and television shows such as the ludicrous, but somehow still entertaining, Hunting Hitler.
I used Google Maps and Google Images to learn more about the places where Sredersas had lived and what had happened at those places. Eventually I found another IRO document, in the Arolsen Archives in Germany, where Sredersas provided yet another version of his career:
From 1935 to 1940 I worked as a policeman. From 1942 to
1944 I worked on a ship as a seaman. From 1946 to 1947 I attended the
Navigation and Sea-Engineering School. From 4th October 1948 to 4th
December 1948 I worked as a seaman.[92]
A
Holocaust survivor from Kovno, Joe Melamed, had in the 1990s compiled and
published lists of the perpetrators of the Holocaust in Lithuania. I wanted to
see if Sredersas was included, but Melamed had died in 2017 and I could not
find his research. Eventually, I found a website called Defending History[93]
which specialises in issues concerning the political and cultural treatment of
the Holocaust in Lithuania. I emailed the site’s administrator, Dr Dovid Katz,
to see if he had Melamed’s lists, but he couldn’t send them to me. Eventually,
I found most of Melamed’s lists published on the personal website of an American
lawyer, but could not see that they included Sredersas’ name.[94]
The letter-opener had writing carved into its panels. There was the year 1963, and the word Vechta, which means ‘old man’ in Lithuanian, while also being, in 1963, a town in West Germany. There was the name Bronius Sredersas and an inscription in Lithuanian. Using Google Translate, I found that the inscription read, ‘Dear Son, a memory from the mother.’ Sredersas had, in 1950, come to Australia alone, and I interpreted this object, apparently sent from his mother 13 years later, with its overtones of nationalist violence, as an interesting way to transmit maternal feelings. The object proved nothing, but like the Iron Wolf – Lithuanian Fishing & Game Association, it was suggestive of the milieu that Sredersas had emerged from.
Sredersas’
letter opener
Table 1: Identifying Bronius Sredersas
|
Birth certificate |
SS enlistment |
IRO registration |
Name |
Bronislav |
Bronislaus |
Bronius |
Surname |
Schreders |
Schroeders |
Sredersas |
Date of birth |
4 December
1910 |
4
December 1910 |
4
December 1910 |
Place of birth |
Simferopol,
Russia |
Simferopol,
Russia |
Simferopol,
Russia |
Religion |
Roman
Catholic |
Roman
Catholic |
Roman
Catholic |
Father’s name |
Maximillian
Gustav Theophil Heinrich Leon Schreders |
Maxs
Gustav Schroeders |
- |
Mother’s name |
Anna-Maria
Schneider |
Anna
Mari Schneider |
- |
Height |
- |
178 cms |
177 cms |
Marital status |
- |
Single |
Single |
Document language and year created |
Russian,
1912 |
German,
1943 |
English,
1947 & 1950 |
Order from the Commander of the S.D., October 3, 1941
The ghetto’s contagious diseases hospital is to be burned down along with its furnishings, patients, and medical personnel. The babies are to be brought to Fort IX.[98]
The
activities of the SD had been considered by the Allies’ International Military
Tribunal at Nuremburg, with the outcome that the SD had, in 1946, been declared
a criminal organisation. The Tribunal concluded:
The Gestapo and SD were used for purposes which
were criminal under the Charter involving the persecution and extermination of
the Jews, brutalities and killings in concentration camps, excesses in the
administration of occupied territories, the administration of the slave labour
programme and the mistreatment and murder of prisoners of war….In dealing with
the SD the Tribunal includes Amts III, VI and VII of the RSHA and all other
members of the SD, including all local representatives and agents, honorary or
otherwise, whether they were technically members of the SS or not.[99]
The SD had also featured in the trial of Adolf Eichmann in
1961, with the judges finding him guilty of being a member of the organisation:
We convict the Accused, pursuant to the fourteenth count,
of membership of a hostile organization, an offence under Section 3(a) of the
above-mentioned Law, in that, as from May 1941, he was a member of the
organization known as Sicherheitsdienst des Reichsfuehrers-SS (SD) which was
declared a criminal organization by the International Military Tribunal which
tried the Major War Criminals, and as a member of such organization he took
part in acts declared criminal in Article 6 of the London Charter of 8 August
1945.[100]
Having established these facts about Sredersas, I knew that further confirmation by an expert in the field was now required. On the advice of both Dovid Katz and Mark Aarons, I sent the documents to Dr Efraim Zuroff, the Coordinator of the Simon Wiesenthal Centre’s Nazi war crimes research effort and a globally acknowledged expert on the Holocaust in Lithuania.
On
12 and 18 January 2022, Dr Zuroff replied confirming my interpretation of the
information contained in the documents:
The fact that in 1943, he worked as a criminal
investigator for the German Sicherheitsdienst in Kaunas (Kovno), means that he
was involved in implementing German policy regarding the Jews, i.e. the
Holocaust.
The question is how long did he serve
there? If, for example, he already served there in the second half of 1941,
when most of the murders of Jews in Lithuania were carried out, then there
is no doubt about his involvement in Holocaust crimes.
Please note that the commander of the German
SD in Lithuania was none other than the mass murderer Karl Jaeger, author of
the infamous "Jaeger Report," which documented the mass murder of
over 137,000 Lithuanian Jews from early July until the end of November 1941.[101]
On
13 January 2022 I contacted John Monteleone, Gallery Director of the Wollongong
Art Gallery, and emailed him the Lithuanian documents and Zuroff’s evaluation.
Monteleone advised he would need to discuss the matter with officers from
Wollongong City Council. On 18 January, I emailed Monteleone again, suggesting
the appropriate course of action for the Gallery would be for it to have an
expert review all the documents available on Sredersas and prepare a report
providing context and an informed historical interpretation. I suggested that
the Sydney Jewish Museum, among others, could undertake such a task.[102]
On 20 January 2022 I received an email from Susan Wardle, Manager Community Cultural and Economic Development (Acting), which provided the Council’s response:
Thank you for the information
- I understand you are deeply concerned about the Gallery’s reputation.
On balance, given the lack of
clear evidence in this case, it is not deemed appropriate for Council - as a
local government body - to undertake such an investigative role as suggested.
As such, Council does not
propose to take any further steps in this matter at this time.[103]
It was astonishing that the Wollongong City Council was apparently not concerned that the Wollongong Art Gallery, a significant cultural institution, was honouring a person who, as an employee of the SD, had been involved in the Holocaust. I decided to take the information I had to the media and contacted Paul Daley, a writer at the Guardian. Having previously written about the mass killings in Lithuania[104], and having met Dr Zuroff in Vilnius, he was immediately interested and commenced work on an article. This involved him travelling to Wollongong, seeing the house Sredersas built in Cringila, and visiting the Wollongong Art Gallery. His substantial and perceptive article, “‘I am Bob. Just Bob’: could a Wollongong folk hero have had a Nazi past?” appeared on 21 March 2022, and contained my comment that the Council “should change the name of the room from the Sredersas Gallery and take down the plaque that honours him. Then they have to tell the story of who he really was.”[105]
Daley’s article generated further media attention in Australia and internationally,[106] and within days the Wollongong City Council changed its position and agreed to engage Professor Konrad Kwiet of the Sydney Jewish Museum to review the information I had provided.[107]
The report found that Sredersas could be classified as a Nazi collaborator, except Professor Kwiet’s work had established Sredersas acquired German citizenship, in Nazi occupied Poland, in June 1941. As such, he didn’t meet the technical definition of a collaborator, being a citizen of one country who traitorously cooperates with the enemy. Instead, Professor Kwiet suggested Sredersas, as a German citizen, could be characterised as one of “Hitler’s Willing Executioners,” implementing Nazi policies and rules in occupied Lithuania.[111]
The Wollongong City Council responded promptly to Professor Kwiet’s report, with Greg Doyle, the Council’s General Manager, stating:
“The history of our gallery, and the city’s
relationship with Sredersas will change from this knowledge. We will respond to
this in a way that is caring, sensitive and culturally appropriate to all
involved. Just how we will do that will now be Council’s immediate focus, and
we will keep our community updated as we move through this process.’’[112]
As a first step, on Friday 24 June 2022, the
plaque honouring Sredersas was removed from the Wollongong Art Gallery, as was
the name plate from the exhibition space previously known as the Sredersas
Gallery.
The plaque honouring Sredersas was removed on 24 June 2022
A New
Story
The Holocaust is one of the most appalling events
of modern history. It sits at the centre of the twentieth century with repercussions,
meanings and reverberations that pass through generations and across continents.
The scale of Hitler’s crime, his attempt to obliterate Europe’s Jews, brought a
new word – genocide – into existence. It is an event that, decades later, still
challenges comprehension.
The Holocaust is not an event with meaning only
for Germans, Jews and Lithuanians. It is something that confronts us all, as
human beings. The war in Europe is already part of Wollongong’s history, with
public memorials dotted around the suburbs honouring local people who served
and died fighting the forces of Nazi Germany in North Africa, the Mediterranean,
and the other theatres of the Second World War. But the Sredersas case is
different as it brings the Holocaust directly from the massacre sites of Kovno
to Wollongong - to its suburbs, steelworks and art gallery.
Post-war Australia was a place where tens of
thousands of survivors came to try to build new lives. It was also one of the
places where perpetrators came to escape the consequences of their criminal
actions. Sredersas lived in industrial obscurity for more than 25 years, lied
repeatedly about his nationality, employment and movements, and was successful in
concealing the truth about his wartime employment for decades.
It is not clear why, after evading detection
for so long, he willingly chose to make himself a figure of renown through his
cultural benefaction. Such a decision carried with it some risk of detection,
but Sredersas must have felt, on balance, that the rewards he obtained
outweighed the risk of exposure. Was he seeking, through the gifting of
artworks to his adopted city, to atone for actions taken earlier in his life?
Did a long suppressed need for social recognition and status, (befitting a nobleman),
finally drive him from anonymity?
These are interesting issues to contemplate,
but the truth about his motivations and personal desires will likely never be
known. What is certain is that Sredersas worked for the murderous SD, concealed
this fact while lying his way through post-war screening, and made a new life
for himself in Wollongong. After years of living unremarkably, he made an
important cultural gift and was well-honoured for it during the remaining years
of his life and in the decades since his death. A historical investigation
established at least some of what Sredersas concealed, and Wollongong will now
no longer honour one of “Hitler’s Willing Executioners.”
With the old story of Sredersas and his gift obsolete and discarded, it is for Wollongong, and in particular the Wollongong Art Gallery, to now tell a new story about Bronius ‘Bob’ Sredersas. A new story that is truthful and conveys a fuller and more accurate account of the man, his life and times, rather than the partial, deceitful, and carefully curated version he wanted told.
Bronius 'Bob' Sredersas
This article was written as an entry for the 2022 Wollongong Local History Prize. It was subsequently published in the Southern Highlands Newsletter and appears here with the kind permission of the Newsletter's Editor.
Michael Samaras - July 2022
Photographs
Bob Sredersas, Unknown photographer,
from the collections of Wollongong City Libraries and the Illawarra
Historical Society
"New Wollongong City Gallery" - a 1991 screenprint by Gregor Cullen celebrating the contribution of Bob Sredersas on the occasion of the Wollongong City Gallery's move into new premises The University of Wollongong, Research Online, https://ro.uow.edu.au/posters/20/
Port Kembla Steelworks, Unknown photographer,
public domain via Wikimedia Commons
Migrants in employment
in Australia - Port Kembla steelworks, 1955, National Archives of Australia, Item ID
7495051
Massacre at the Kovno Garage – June 1941, Unknown photographer,
public domain via Wikimedia Commons
Einsatzgruppen or their auxiliaries – Kovno 1942, Unknown photographer,
public domain via Wikimedia Commons
Promotional flyer for the fundraising Sredersas Dinner & Lecture, 2018, Wollongong Art Gallery website
The document confirming Sredersas' place in the Tsar's aristocracy, photographed by the author, 2021
Sredersas’ letter
opener,
photographed by the author, 2021
The plaque honouring Sredersas was removed on 24 June 2022, photographed by the author, 2022
Bronius 'Bob' Sredersas, Unknown photographer, from the collections of Wollongong City Libraries and the Illawarra Historical Society
Notes
[1]
Illawarra Mercury, 27 July 1976
[2]
Death certificate extracted from the New South Wales Registry of Births, Deaths
and Marriages on 5 January 2022
[3]
The artworks and objects are catalogued in Kate Halley’s Bob Sredersas, published by the Wollongong City Gallery, in an
expanded version, on the “20th anniversary of this gift”, undated
but presumably 1996 or 1998.
[4] Blog post titled Commentary by Harold Hanson AM
regarding the establishment of the Wollongong City Art Gallery, dated 26 February 2013 and accessed on 12 April
2022 at http://tedsrerant.blogspot.com/2013/02/ commentaryby-harold-hanson-am-regarding.html
[5] Illawarra Mercury, 18 May 1979
[6] Illawarra Mercury, 8 November 1978
[7] Illawarra Mercury, 18 May 1979
[8] Illawarra Mercury ,27 May 1982
[9]
Jones, Barry, The IV Bob Sredersas
Memorial Lecture, accessed at the National Archives of Australia, NAA: M4504, 22/11/1990
[10] http://www.wollongongartgallery.com/friends/Documents/The%20Sredersas%20Dinner%20and%20
Lecture%20eflyer.pdf
[11] Lever-Tracy,
Constance and Quinlan, Michael, A Divided
Working Class: Ethnic Segmentation and Industrial Conflict in Australia, London,
Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1988, p193.
[12] Steinke, John and Stokes, Leigh, Wollongong
Statistical Handbook 2, Department of Economics, University of Wollongong,
1980
[13]
Horne, Donald, The Lucky Country,
Third revised edition, Penguin Books, Ringwood, 1966, p 54.
[14]
Schultz, Julianne, Steel City Blues,
Ringwood, Victoria, Penguin Books, 1985, p11.
[15]
Whitlam, Gough, The Whitlam Government
1972-1975, Viking, Melbourne, 1985, p 323.
[16] Illawarra Mercury, 3 June 1978
[17]
Sometimes referred to as the Soviet Union or Soviet Russia.
[18] Migrant Selection Documents for Displaced Persons who
travelled to Australia per Fairsea departing Bremerhaven 18 April 1950,
National Archives of Australia
[19]
Ibid
[20]
IRO papers held in the National Archives of Australia, NAA: 12027, 459
[21] Migrant Selection Documents for Displaced Persons who
travelled to Australia per Fairsea departing Bremerhaven 18 April 1950,
National Archives of Australia
[22] Illawarra Mercury, 18 May 1979
[23]
The birth certificate is in Russian. It and a translation into English are held
in the Local Studies section of the Wollongong City Library.
[24]
The city Kaunas is known by different names in different languages including
Kovno, Kauen and Kowno.
[25] Illawarra Mercury, 13 April 1982.
[26]
Senn, Alfred, ‘Lithuanian Surnames’, The
American Slavic and East European Review , Aug., 1945, Vol. 4, No. 1/2
(Aug., 1945), pp. 127-137.
[27]
Accessed at Statistics Lithuania on 19 April 2022: http://www.stat.gov.lt/uploads/leidiniai/Lietuvos_gyv_sur.pdf page xxxvi
[28]
Kassow, Samuel D, in his introduction to The
Clandestine History of the Kovno Jewish Ghetto Police by Anonymous Police,
Indiana University Press, 2014, p6-8
[29]
Ibid, viii
[30]
Snyder, Timothy, Black Earth: The
Holocaust as History and Warning, Tim Duggan Books, New York, 2015, p 139.
[31]
IRO papers held in the Arolsen Archives. Document number: 81205727 at
collections.arolsen-archives.org accessed 14 April 2022
[32]
Extracts from this document are held in the Wollongong City Library Local
Studies collection and have been translated into English.
[33]
Bubnys, Arunas, The Holocaust in
Lithuania, Genocide and Resistance Research Centre of Lithuania, Vilnius,
2008, p18.
[34]
IRO papers held in the National Archives of Australia, NAA: 12027, 459
[35]
Snyder, Timothy, Op cit, p141.
[36]
Wikipedia entry on Augustinas Povilaitis, accessed on 23 April 2022.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Augustinas_Povilaitis
[37]
The NKVD
(People's Commissariat for
Internal Affairs) was the security agency of the Soviet Union and an instrument
of Stalin’s terror.
[38]
Snyder, Timothy, Op cit, p 22.
[39]
Tory, Avraham, Surviving the Holocaust:
The Kovno Ghetto Diary, Harvard University Press, 1990, p251, 230, and 411.
[40]
The Holocaust Encyclopaedia of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
accessed on 25 April 2022: https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/kovno
[41]
Friedlander, Saul, Nazi Germany and the
Jews 1939-1945: The Years of Extermination, HarperCollins, New York, 2007,
p222.
[42]
Anonymous, The Clandestine History of the
Kovno Jewish Ghetto Police, Indiana University Press, 2014, pp 132-146.
[43]
The Jaeger Report is widely available on websites, but can be found as an
appendix in Ginaite-Rubinson, Sara, Resistance
and Survival: The Jewish Community in Kaunas 1941-1944, Mosaic Press, 2005,
pp231-238.
[44]
Bubnys, Arunas, Op cit, p 4.
[45]
For a detailed account of life in the Kovno ghetto see Tory, Avraham Surviving the Holocaust: the Kovno Ghetto
Diary, Harvard University Press, Massachusetts, 1990.
[46]
Ginaite-Rubinson, Sara, Resistance and
Survival: The Jewish Community in Kaunas 1941-1944, Mosaic Press, 2005,
pp197-208.
[47]
Bubnys, Arunas, Op cit, p 51.
[48]
Bubnys, Arunas, Ibid, p 42.
[49]
Timothy Snyder, Lithuania neglects the
memory of its murdered Jews, The Guardian 30 July 2011, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2011/jul/29/lithuania-murdered-jews-wartime-crimes
[50]
The Jaeger Report, Appendix in Ginaite-Rubinson, Sara, Resistance and Survival: The Jewish Community in Kaunas 1941-1944,
Mosaic Press, 2005, pp231-238.
[51]
IRO papers held in the National Archives of Australia, NAA: 12027,459. After
the war, Heilsberg was transferred from Germany to Poland and is now known as Lidzbark
Warmiński.
[52]
IRO papers held in the National Archives of Australia, NAA: 12027,459
[53]
Ward, Russell, A Nation for a Continent:
the history of Australia 1901-1975, Heinemann Educational Australia,
Richmond, 1977, pp301, 327-331.
[54]
This point is made by Ritter David, “Distant Reverberations: Australian
Responses to the Trial of Adolf Eichmann”, in Lawson, Tom and Jordan, James,
(eds) The Memory of the Holocaust in
Australia, London, Valentine Mitchell, 2008, p52.
[55]
Search conducted on Trove, with the article “An Indictment of the German
People” appearing on 8 June 1945. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/132646345?searchTerm=Auschwitz
[56]
Ritter, Op cit, p66
[57]
Wajnryb, Ruth, The Silence: How Tragedy
Shapes Talk, St Leonards, Allen and Unwin, 2001, p 32.
[58]
Lateo, Karen, Interview with Bob Sredersas, 29 May 1981, transcript provided by
Anne-Louise Rentell.
[59]
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-05-26/how-a-lithuanian-intelligence-officer-helped-establish-gallery/9799460
[60] Blog post titled Commentary by Harold Hanson AM regarding the
establishment of the Wollongong City Art Gallery, dated 26 February 2013 and accessed on 12 April 2022 at http://tedsrerant.blogspot.com/2013/02/
[61]
Lateo, Karen, Op cit.
[62] Illawarra Mercury, 27 May 1982.
[63]
Clohesy, Lachlan, Australian Cold
Warrior: The Anti-Communism of W. C. Wentworth, Doctorate of Philosophy,
Victoria University, 2010, pp174-176.
[64]
House of Representatives, Hansard, 16
March 1961, p371.
[65] Ibid
[66]
Aarons, Mark, War Criminals Welcome:
Australia, a Sanctuary for Fugitive War Criminals Since 1945, Black Inc,
Melbourne, 2001, p444.
[67]
The name of the Wollongong City Gallery was changed to the Wollongong Art
Gallery in 2013.
[68]
Wollongong Art Gallery website, http://www.wollongongartgallery.com/exhibitions/Pages/THE-GIFT-Bob-Sredersas.aspx,
accessed on 1 May 2022
[69] Wollongong
Art Gallery, The Gift, Program of
Events, website accessed 1 May 2022
[70] ABC Illawarra, The
Lithuanian secret service officer whose art collection changed an Australian
city, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-05-26/how-a-lithuanian-intelligence-officer-helped-establish-a-gallery/9799460,
accessed 1 May 2022
[71] Illawarra Mercury, 25 May 2018
[72]
See for example Friedlander, Saul, Op cit,
p221-233.
[73]
IRO papers held in the National Archives of Australia, NAA: 12027, 459
[74]
Naturalisation papers in the National Archives of Australia NAA C321,
N1969/65175
[75]
Naturalisation papers in the National Archives of Australia NAA C321,
N1969/65175
[76] Sanctuary: Nazi Fugitives in Australia,
Ratlines: How the Vatican’s Nazi Networks Betrayed Western Intelligence to the
Soviets (with John Loftus) and War
Criminals Welcome: Australia, a Sanctuary for Fugitive War Criminals since 194.
[77]
Email from Mark Aarons to the author on 6 July 2019.
[78] Statement of Reasons issued to me by the
National Archives of Australia on 17 July 2019.
[79]
Email from the National Archives of Australia to the author 22 August 2019.
[80]
These papers are in the Arolsen Archive: https://collections.arolsen-archives.org/en/search/person/81065726?s=Juozas%20Krucas&t=20470&p=1
[81] Sudbury Star, 25 August 2002, https://thesudburystar.remembering.ca/obituary/juozas-krucas-1076227922
[82]
MacQueen, Michael, “The Context of Mass Destruction: Agents and Prerequisites
of the Holocaust in Lithuania”, in Holocaust
and Genocide Studies, Vol 12, No 1, 1998, p38.
[83]
Kate Halley’s “Bob Sredersas”, published by the Wollongong City Gallery, in an
expanded version, on the “20th anniversary of this gift”, undated
but presumably 1996 or 1998.
[84]
Heraldry certificate held in the Local Studies section of the Wollongong
Library.
[85] http://holocaustatlas.lt/EN/#a_atlas/search//page/1/item/125/
accessed on 8 May 2022
[86] genocid.lt/centras/en/
[87]
Email from Arunas Bubnys to the author on 29 July 2019.
[88]
Bubnys, Arunas, The Holocaust in Lithuania
between 1941 and 1944, Genocide and Resistance Research Centre of
Lithuania, Vilnius 2008.
[89] Ibid, p15
[90]
Sereny, Gitta, Into That Darkness: From
Mercy Killing to Mass Murder, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1974
[91]
Steinacher, Gerald, Nazis on
the Run: How Hitler’s Henchmen Fled Justice, Oxford University Press, Oxford,
2011.
[92]
Arolsen Archives, Reference 171 8000 collections.arolsen-archives.org/en/search/person/81205725?s=Sredersas&t=20470&p=1
[93]
defendinghistory.com
[94] https://grantgochin.com/blog/
[95]
Ley, Robert, Organisationsbuch der NSDAP,
Munich, NSDAP, 1943, see plates 66 and 69 following page 469 and plates 7 and
72 following page 470. Available at Wikimedia Commons
[96] Lithuanian Central State Archives, F
r-656, Ap 1, D 1581
[97] Snyder, Timothy, Op cit, p 41 and 84
[98]
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Hidden
History of the Kovno Ghetto, Washington, 1997, p 64.
[99] The judgements made at Nuremburg are available online at: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/imt/judorg.asp#gestapo
[100]
The judgement of the Eichmann trial are available online at: https://www.asser.nl/upload/documents/DomCLIC/Docs/NLP/Israel/Eichmann_Judgement_11-12-1961.pdf
[101]
Email from Dr Efraim Zuroff to the author, 18 January 2022.
[102]
Email from the author to John Monteleone, 18 January 2022
[103]
Email from Susan Wardle to the author, 20 January 2022
[104]
Daley, Paul, “Hitler’s Henchmen”, The
Bulletin, 2 March 2004, p16-22.
[105]
Daley, Paul, ‘I am Bob. Just Bob’: could a
Wollongong folk hero have had a Nazi past? Guardian, 21 March 2022
[106]
For example, see Wollongong’s Illawarra
Mercury 22 March 2022, the American website Forward https://forward.com/news/462659/nazi-collaborator-monuments-in-australia/?fbclid=IwAR00RgiXeAEuxOwoly56_EGBE9pnOrdTfY3JoN4glZOUaIekQWLS5Peyg3M,
and the Lithuanian website Lrytas https://www.lrytas.lt/pasaulis/rytai-vakarai/2022/04/17/news/australija-soke-meno-kolekcija-dovanojo-naciu-kolaborantas-is-lietuvos-23078734
[107] Kurmelovs,
Royce, “Jewish
Museum to lead
investigation into claim Wollongong identity collaborated with Nazis”, Guardian, 1 April 2022
[108]
Emeritus Professor Konrad Kwiet, Executive
Summary,2 June 2022
[109]
Emeritus Professor Konrad Kwiet, Preliminary
Report: The Nazi Allegations raised against Bronius Serdersas, submitted to
the Wollongong City Council, 19 May 2022.
[110]
Ibid
[111] Ibid. The term comes from a history
published by Daniel Goldhagen.
[112]
Media statement issued by the Wollongong City Council, 22 June 2022
Comments
Post a Comment